Thoughts, please!

It’s just occurred to me that ‘If God Will Send His Angels’ by U2 is cover-able.

U2 - ‘If God Will Send His Angels’

Is it? Am I mad for thinking that this could be done by a jazz trio? Or even beautifully with just voice and piano?

[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]

12 Responses to “Thoughts, please!”

  1. John Q Says:

    I’m not familiar with that song and youtube is blocked here so I don’t know. Has it got proper chords or it is all just sus2 type chords that only the Edge can play ?
    I’ll try and get to hear it.

  2. Andrea Says:

    this gives you a wee snippet -

    http://www.last.fm/music/U2/_/If+God+Will+Send+His+Angels

    - sadly, it kicks in just after that clip ends. doh!

  3. Peter Thompson Says:

    i reckon it is probably do-able, though as usual, the distinct lack of any musical progression in U2’s songs makes it difficult. They are called U2 because all their songs have Under 2 chords.

  4. Peter Thompson Says:

    actually it has three I think, so it may work!

  5. Andrea Says:

    ha! now only if it were three chords and the truth, it’d be Springsteen.

    hmm.. maybe it’s one of those tracks which is a great recording, but not necessarily a great song.

  6. Rachel Says:

    I don’t know ONE chord.

  7. Jack Says:

    The only chord I know is the one I pull so I can see in the bathroom when it’s dark.

  8. Rachel Says:

    I can’t even find that chord most times

  9. Matt S Says:

    i think if you are looking at U2 songs, the starting point must be The Joshua Tree - which i really didnt like much when it came out but love now. how about ‘i still havent found what i am looking for’ or ‘with or without you’ ? both i think could be slowed down quite nicely, but i would have to leave the chord bit to you i’m afraid !

  10. John Q Says:

    I had wondered about songs from the Joshua Tree as well (more my era :) ) and thought they might lend themselves to a bit of a jazz treatment (bearing in mind the taste and musicality mentioned earlier in the week). Perhaps a bit of a bossaey type feel would work for either of the ones that Matt mentions.
    Going back even further perhaps ‘In the name of love’ ?
    It’s surprising what can work. I heard a version of The music of the night from Phantom done as a jazz waltz once which actually worked.
    I also heard a version of the theme tune to Schindler’s List which didn’t work at all…

  11. Andrea Says:

    Matt - much as I love ‘The Joshua Tree’, I think those two songs are a) waaaaaay too famous to even attempt, unless you’re in a rock band and doing it as your Obligatory Interesting-Or-Crowd-Pleasing Cover; and b) examples of great recordings but not interesting songs per se. so as a result they wouldn’t stand up to being stripped down. which is a nice turn of phrase… but I digress. to be covered in the jazz styleee, there has to be a jazz sensibility in there somewhere… and in ‘If God Will Send His Angels’, there is. or at least, I hear one. I was curious to see if anyone else heard it too :-).

    speaking of finding obscure(ish) U2 songs to cover, Cassandra Wilson saw the jazziness and beauty in ‘Love Is Blindness’ and did a great job (as always) of covering it - http://www.last.fm/music/Cassandra+Wilson/_/Love+Is+Blindness

    John - you know what, I bet ‘In The Name Of Love’ is a great song. in terms of its writing. I’m just not sure whether I could be the person to do that cover. and the chords strike me as very poppy.. but then it could be arranged. as it were.

  12. Andrea Says:

    PS thank you all for your input. even about bathroom chords. :-)

Leave a Reply