The white stuff
When I first arrived in Penang, I noticed that the hotel’s spa offered a range of treatments. One of these was a facial which involved ‘whitening’. I didn’t think much of it - I don’t tend to, where this silly ‘beautifying’ malarkey is concerned - although I’m sure I vaguely wondered whether that meant the facial also included whitening your teeth. “How interesting,” I thought. And how wrong I was.
Not that the idea of a facial which also offers teeth-whitening isn’t interesting. Indeed, it’s so “interesting” as to be “completely silly”. Because, obviously, I got it completely wrong - as multiple trips to the pharmacy next door over the past few months have proved.
While the beauty products - or more precisely, the skincare products - on offer in a Malaysian pharmacy look exactly like the ones for sale back in the West, more than a cursory glance shows that there’s one, rather stark, difference. It’s the presence of products like this:
and this:
Yes, my fellow Western ladies: we may think we have it tough, being subjected to the pressure to be thin. But women in the East not only face that (slimming and dieting products are everywhere here, too - despite, or perhaps because of, the general smaller build of Asians); they are also told that they should be more white.
As this article in the New Straits Times pussyfoots around says, the culture here rather uncomfortably tells people - and most specifically, women - that it is desirable to have skin as white as possible; and there are all manner of beauty products (and spa treatments) on hand to make that happen. Lancome, Chanel, Estee Lauder, Clinique, Dior, Olay… they’re all at it.
Clearly there’s a link here between being white and being of a higher class, as well as the implication that it is better to look as least ‘Asian’ as possible. Being of a darker skin is associated with being of a race that is more undesirable; or of a lower class (all that working outdoors in manual jobs).
Conversely, of course, we in the West see having darker skin - but not too dark, mind! - as something desirable, as at its roots it has the association with being either a) healthy (all that time spent outdoors) or b) rich (all that leisure time spent outdoors).
It’s all very strange, and rather worrying. Where will it end? Well, apart from ‘with Michael Jackson’, that is?












March 27th, 2008 at 3.12am
Horrible. But it will change. The British used to wear powder to make themselves look whiter and having a tan was seen as being associated with rural workers. When China rules the world (probably next Tuesday) westerners will start dying their hair black and straight and having their eyes made less round probably. But it is a pretty good indication of real power and real class in a world where apparently neither exists any more or has been diffused.
March 27th, 2008 at 3.15am
Isn’t it great how our most beloved corporations react to customer demand though? Inspiring! You gotta love ‘em - or shut them down.
March 27th, 2008 at 3.19am
yes, free market capitalism has no room for ethical manoeuvering, does it? when would a company (eg a hotel, a pharmacy) ever take a stand and say: ‘we don’t approve of this product on moral/ethical grounds, so we’re not going to stock it’? answer: never.
March 27th, 2008 at 7.13am
A has seen this - I’ve taken a closer look. On sale in the United Arab Emirates: http://www.flickr.com/photos/86338173@N00/2351446548/sizes/l/
Made in the Phillipines.
Picture taken next to some comedy soap sent by my brother at Christmas. The UJ is not an intentional placement.
March 27th, 2008 at 7.14am
Hugh was worried about his freckles. Hugh’s brother was worried about Hugh’s trouser pant region.
March 28th, 2008 at 1.45am
Gosh, that’s really worrying. Blimey, I despair. What’s wrong with folk just being folk?
March 28th, 2008 at 11.25am
Sarah - yes, it’s awful. but I guess just a natural extension of the sort of crap we see in the West, too. how about creams trying to make us look younger?!
March 28th, 2008 at 4.40pm
or Converse All-Stars
March 28th, 2008 at 5.11pm
ha! but hey, don’t knock them. if they’re good enough for The Doctor, they’re good enough for anyone.